[linux-audio-dev] Re: mouse wheel behavior and RFC: human interface guidelines

[Artem Baguinski]

John Check wrote:

>>Sorry, I disagree.  This kind of thing is MADDENING for users and makes
>>Linux look fly-by-night.
>>
> 
> 
> That presumes we have a monopoly on inconsistency. ;) 

no we don't ;)

on any system where one can install components there will allways be 
inconsistency. mutations make sure the species... sorry interfaces evolve.

> Having a consistent interface will definitely work to our advantage, but
> I'm talking about near term when I say things like that. Being as I'm not 
> going to be the one coding, I can't say "must" or "has to".
> 

"consistent interface" is idealisation that professors of human 
interaction use. it's a useful idealisation but it has troubled 
surviving in the real world.

if the whole bunch of people sais the consistent behavior is braindead - 
it's better off changed. after all the goal of consistency was to make 
people not notice the interface.

> 
>>Of course, you can't force people to follow human interface guidelines
>>in the free software world.  All we can do is carefully develop them
>>based on what users want, then if you choose not to comply you are
>>explicitly stating that you are hubristically choosing to ignore the
>>users need for a consistent experience.

people do not need consistent experience, people need to get the work 
done. consistency is one of the tools that make getting the work done 
easier, but it isn't a goal in itself.