[LAU] Music made with Linux

[Patrick Shirkey]

David Collins wrote:
> Hi, here are three pieces made with a Debian system - mostly timidity++,
> RoseGarden, and ecasound.
>
> Two songs:
>  - http://indigo.uk.to/~david/music/32/32-instrumental.ogg
>  - http://indigo.uk.to/~david/music/68/68.ogg
>
> And a neo-classical piece:
>  - http://indigo.uk.to/~david/music/36/36.ogg
>
> There are notes about the production of each piece in a 'NOTES' file
> in the corresponding HTTP directory ( e.g. http://indigo.uk.to/~david/music/32/NOTES ).
>
> I have very little experience with mastering, and the last piece in
> particular needs a lot of work. I don't have much time to work on
> these at the moment, but constructive criticism is welcome.
>   
I think your levels are fine.

In 32 there are a few samples that you have chosen which immediately 
make the mix dated. They are just too much like old midi sounds for my 
ear. Also the lead in drum roll is too even and non dynamic. I think you 
could make a big difference by adjusting the timing on that to be more 
realistic. You have got it right for the tympani on 36.

I really like the atmosphere of 36. Brooding.

Again with 68 the samples are too dated for my taste. The composition, 
mix and levels create a nice Eagles/Roxette/Eurythmics type of vibe 
though. Which has it's place.



Cheers.




-- 
Patrick Shirkey
Boost Hardware Ltd.