[LAU] theora and html5

hollunder hollunder at lavabit.com
Tue Feb 16 19:30:29 EST 2010


Excerpts from nettings's message of 2010-02-16 22:20:54 +0100:
> On 02/16/2010 09:41 PM, hollunder wrote:
> > Excerpts from Jörn Nettingsmeier's message of 2010-02-16 21:22:48 +0100:
> >> (sticks a cardboard periscope on head, dances about and chants "i'm the
> >> submarine patent threat")
> >
> > And one can get you with any format :)
> 
> that should be really obvious to you and me. not so in corporate droid 
> brains...
> 
> > Most concerns seem to go into the quality and filesize direction, so if
> > it got a lot better the information should be spread somehow.
> 
> well, it definitely got a lot better. it is still slightly inferior to 
> almost every proprietary codec out there, but guess what: i don't care, 
> because it's good enough for web content.
> cpu is getting cheaper by second, bandwith even more so.
> 
> the trade-off between huge licensing costs for content creators, vendor 
> lock-in and closed-source plugin hassles on the one hand ("oh, you're 
> using $fooBSD? so sorry, we are not going to implement it, and we won't 
> let you do it, either") and a couple of cycles here and a few kbits 
> there doesn't really compute anymore.
> 
> many of the articles in wikipedia are demonstrably inferior to those in 
> <your favourite encyclopedia here> - still, the whole concept is so 
> immensely powerful that it has become my number one resource, while that 
> 16-tome dead-tree-pulp monster from the early nineties is gathering dust 
> on my bookshelf.
> to me, that same analogy holds for theora compared to <your favourite 
> codec here>. it's important to know the limitations (theora sure as hell 
> isn't going to replace blu-ray disks anytime soon), but for web, it 
> would work like a charm.

I basically agree, so it's a matter of getting the information/opinion
out there. For me last years lac video quality was fine, and I was
watching it live (thanks ;)). I said that in a comment on some html
guy's html5/video blog that asked for opinion and I hope it helps in
some way.
The question really is: how do you demonstrate that theora is there? How
do you manage to get word out into the world that it actually is good
enough and has benefits?



More information about the Linux-audio-user mailing list