2009/9/3  <hollunder@gmx.at>
I'm using a WM (called awesome) that can do tiling for everyday tasks as
well as audio. Since I have a rather small screen I use it mostly to get
every app fullscreen. When trying to use it for audio I ran in some
trouble. Applications like ardour require a lot of screen estate, on my
screen it hardly fits on the screen. Many other apps have a similar
minimum size that is simply not handled gracefully, at least by this WM.
Another problem is with applications that don't resize at all or that
apparently can't be handled in tiling mode. One such example is jkmeter.

So from my experience with awesome I'd say that it's theoretically a
nice idea but doesn't quite work that way. When you look at the
screenshots at tiling WM homepages you see mostly terminals, probably
for a reason. Maybe other WMs work better, but from my experience I'd
say that a WM that remembers window positions or where you could
specify them would probably work better, but I still have to explore
if that's possible with my WM.

Yes, exactly my thoughts. Tiling WM is simply not a solution as some apps, Ardour primarily, actually _need_ all the space it can get. Not all of us have > 19" or dual monitors even when it's the age of HD and Blue Ray. In fact, as things go mobile and portable more, the less screen space is favoured.

KDE has the potential to provide this 100%, but it needs to smoothen up its cosmetics against usability since wihout compositing (which is a major penalty for Intel graphics) it looks worse than my LXDE environment.