Yes and no. DVI-I connectors actually carry BOTH the Digital and Analog VGA signal. That dongle removes the VGA signal from the cable and changes the connector to match a VGA port. It does not convert betweent he two. The main thing to look for to see if you can do this is the 4 pins around the flat bar'ish looking thing. A straight DVI connector with only a digital signal will not have these, while a DVI-I connection will and will carry the analog signal on those 4 pins.
However if all you have is a digital signal, you will have to convert, which as already pointed out is a bit on the expensive side.
Seablade