Good advice, and I did just that.
The results are equal in size, but in quality Opus clearly wins in this scenario.
Big Question No. 2:
On Sat, Apr 15, 2023 at 03:58:12PM -0700, Len Ovens wrote:
On Sat, 15 Apr 2023, D.T. wrote:
* personally, I always had the feeling that opus (used a lot by youtube)
isn't so good with noisy, grungy, fuzzy, guitarry music
Well, don't use something you don't like :)
I would almost suggest to try them all. I would think changing the
codec is just a change the parameter, restart kind of thing. It
doesn't have to be on the target machine for testing, just use which
ever machine has the files on (or at least a good chunk of them).
To see what a given input file sounds like after being transcoded to
each of several different output formats, at a couple of different
bitrates in your range of interest, just run a for loop in Bash, no?
Something like (untested):
for i in {m4a,ogg,opus}; do
for j in {64k,96k}; do
ffmpeg -i infile.flac -b:a "$j" outfile_"$j"."$i"
done
done
Tweak this for more detail if desired.
Then listen to the results, and go with whichever combination of bitrate
& codec you find most satisfying?
Sam
_______________________________________________