[LAU] Prog rock instrumental, sort-of WIP

Q lists at quirq.ukfsn.org
Wed Oct 28 17:56:46 EDT 2009


Folderol wrote:

> Al though the music I'm most comfortable with is fairly 'mainstream' I
> did in fact very much enjoy this. There were a lot of (to me)
> unexpected changes but that didn't jar as I've found it does with some
> compositions. Very much liked the changes in sound texture and the
> dynamics.
> 

Thanks for listening, especially as it's a bit outside your comfort 
zone: that means a lot then that you enjoyed it so much -- I'm glad.

"Unexpected changes" is good and not jarring is even better :-)

I have worried a bit about the transitions, I often see reviews 
criticising particular "epic" prog tracks because the band has strung 
together a load of segments that don't really go that well together, 
with no cohesion or sense of... well, progression I suppose!

I guess there's a fine line between keeping things surprising yet 
coherent and them being shocking and not really working because several 
disparate ideas have been forced together at gunpoint. I suppose jarring 
is good if that's the intention -- I was aiming for unexpected but 
unjarring and it seems like I succeeded.

Thanks again.

Best wishes

Q



More information about the Linux-audio-user mailing list