On Thu, Feb 06, 2003 at 01:27:39 -0500, Paul Davis wrote:
Again, I think
we are speaking of slightly different things. I am talking
about the time when (for example) the synth at the head of the chain has
stopped playing notes. A reverb with this as it's input would be told 'your
input is now silent'. It has a tail, of course. It can be marked silent
when it's tail is done. Once it is silent, it does not need to be
processed._
this sounds very dangerous to me.
your description sounds OK. but ... my kawai k5000 is an additive
synth with a moderately interesting FX bank. its still producing sound
for most patches long after all of its "voices" are off. if someone
were to write a plugin modelled on this kind of design, you can't
really know when the top of the chain is silent.
I agree, and more than that its not a usful optimisation (in RT
processing), I dont htink the offline case is important enough to warrent
this level of complexit and debugging nightmare.
If you can point me to a working (not pure research) implemntation I will
consider that it might not be total insanity ;)
- Steve