On 09/02/2009 06:48 AM, Florent Berthaut wrote:
Hi everyone,
i'm happy to learn about this new direction for lash. It looks really
promising.
The goal: "collaborate with x11 wm ..." reminded of an idea i had this
summer during the RMLL ("rencontres mondiales du logiciel libre") while
talking with musicians of the windows world.
They told me that they liked the gnu approach ("one application for one
task"), that it was great to be able to change a part of the workflow
independently. They also obvioulsy liked the idea of lash, being able to
save and recall a session.
But what they worried about (especially ableton live users) was the fact
that a great number of windows could become complicated to handle
compared to single window applications as live.
So the idea of remembering the windows positions is a good point but i
think another interesting point would be to have an application that
grabs all the music applications' windows and tiles them automatically
(of course with the possibilities of resizing and moving each tile)
So when you restore a session all the windows are accessible at once.
This would be a sort of musical window manager and would allow to
combine the advantage of a single window application with the advantages
of multiple interconnected applications.
Perhaps it already exists, if it does please let me know ;)
I have had this idea for a while and your diea would compliment it very
well.
Basically the window manager should provide a hook for the app to have a
jack port on the title bar. This would then allow the window manager to
control teh layout and location of all apps with a jack port.
Alternatively it could also use ladish to provide the wrapper to all the
ladish/jack apps.
I know it is early days since Nedko just released his updates to the
system but I think we have an opportunity to provide this integration
from a window management perspective. In my mind it is a logical and
inevitable feature that will give desktop users a game like graphical
management option they can play with and get excited about.