Re: [LAD] GUI for audio application

On Mon, Dec 28, 2009 at 09:11:44PM +0100, Carlo Ascani wrote: Ah, libprolooks. I guess it could use some updates from CALF again, so try to get hold of hansfbaier or kfoltman (both hang around in #lad on freenode) I agree with almost everything except the vumeter. They are for analog equipment, but we're talking digital domain here. The usual criticism applies: unclear headroom, something like 50% of the meter for the upmost 3dB, multiple definitions for the needle's attack and release, just to name a few. VUmeters are no more than eye candy, if possible, stick to digital bar meters. It's also worth to have a look at the K metering system, i.e. K14, K12 and K10. Unlike Ralf, I support the idea of an inspiring GUI. It's sometimes half of the creative process to have a GUI which invites you to play around as long as usability isn't completely ruined. Also note that sampo is working on some GUI stuff, too, so you could jump that band waggon: http://thorwil.wordpress.com/2009/12/03/compressor-plugin-gui/ More links for your convenience: Old calf: http://calf.sourceforge.net/?id=4 libprolooks: http://www.hansfbaier.de/wordpress/libprolooks/ (GUI extracted from old calf) New calf: http://foltman.com/Deesser.png Especially the last one looks pretty decent to me. HTH -- mail: adi(a)thur.de http://adi.thur.de PGP/GPG: key via keyserver