31 Jan
2004
31 Jan
'04
2:09 p.m.
The label "drclaw(a)dogsolitude.org" hathe been affixed to this message,
...His songs, guy.
I was just attempting to point out that the formats themselves do not
constrain the ability of the composer to write music in one style or
another. You could write a piece with an acceptable piano simulation
.mod seems a bit limiting to me... If your samples are too large they drag a
bit, files get huge, etc. I don't think I've actually played one since about
1994 or so though and that was on my 486/25. :} I could very well be mistaken.
You're pretty much stuck with a tracker to play or compose in as well, no? It
might be nice if mods were implemented as an actual, portable form of midi
though...
{like if you could export them from your sequencer with imbedded .wav
files.}
:} My point was that they're his songs... he knows how he likes them.
On Fri, Jan 30, 2004 at 04:12:17PM -0600, RTaylor
wrote:
> The label "drclaw(a)dogsolitude.org" hathe been affixed to this message,
> >On Wed, Jan 28, 2004 at 03:52:38PM -0500, Dominic Genest wrote:
Mine are
rather "piano only", classical-like, songs. Those usually sound
better with midi sequencers.
I would have to completely disagree. It isn't that one is "better" than
the other, they both have pluses and minuses. At a certain level, in either format. What constrains the composer is the
amount of support
for "piano" sounds he could find related to these formats. If this was
a commercial project, I could think of numerous commercial MIDI synths
that have decent piano simulations, the problem is that I personally
haven't heard any good piano simulations of the free software variety,
and plugging in your own piano sounds is just as easy with a tracked
song as with a MIDI song.
You can use the same sound fonts or instruments in either system.
This is excellent.
http://www.personalcopy.com/sfarkfonts1.htm
These are the companies that made the samples that shipped with sonar.
Many of them are excellent as well: They're just .wav files... :} pretty much
cross-platform.
www.aka-online.de
www.backintimerecords.de
www.boldersounds.com
www.ericvonbayer.us
www.handheldsound.com
www.manytone.com
www.maz-sound.com
www.prosoundbank.com
--
See these tears so blue. An ageless heart that can never mend.
Tears can never dry. A judgement made can never bend.
...
And I've been putting out fire with gasoline...
{Dave}