Hi Joern,
On Sunday 18 January 2009 07:00:06 you wrote:
nescivi wrote:
On Wednesday 14 January 2009 12:54:12 Jörn
Nettingsmeier wrote:
wow!
the paper did not mention this, but did you have any packet losses
through birds? or bird losses through packets?
very rarely we did indeed have packet losses across the laser link, but
since they were so few and far between (even in bad weather), i don't
have reliable data. one possible weakness in the whole scheme is that
the UDP redundancy methods of both jacktrip and netjack will send
redundant packets right next to each other, so that if you have a burst
failure (which is common), you are screwed.
ok.
Not so much a bird city, Cologne, I guess ;)
and not the trecking season... so probably there were not so many bird swarms
gathering to head south.
for me, the morale is: lasers can be made reliable
enough if you can
tolerate the occasional single or short burst packet loss (loss rates of
about 0.0001%), the general internet cannot, unless you get end-to-end
QoS, but you can sneak past that if you have lots more bandwidth than
you are going to need. but nothing in the world short of http streaming
will protect your ass against crappy border gateways and switches that
barf on udp stream traffic.
as to bird losses, the class 3 lasers operated at 8mW, so the chance of
a bird being vaporised is, ahem, slim.
the main issue with respect to laser safety was eye damage. the minimum
safe distance to look directly into the laser was about 50m. but since
IR lasers do not trigger a lid-closing reflex (you only see a dim red
shimmer), this minimum safe distance is determined for a duration of
100s of continuously staring into the lens (for lasers in the visible
range, this duration is below 1s, iirc). so you would actually have to
hover in front of the laser for well over a minute before your retina
takes serious damage. therefore, we can safely rule out eye damage to
birds as well, unless they are very skilled flyers, very bored and very
very stupid.
What the visible range of birds? Maybe they could see the beam?
Just curious...
Thanks for the elaborate answer :)
sincerely,
Marije