25 Aug
2005
25 Aug
'05
6:49 p.m.
On Thu, 2005-08-25 at 14:57 -0400, davidrclark(a)earthlink.net wrote:
Paul Davis,
Before sounding off like you did, I suggest you *do
your homework*.
Negative. You have used an inappropriate public forum to cast serious
doubts on the usefulness of someone's work. Based on communications here
by the author of that work, it appears you have not raised these issues
with the author prior to posting here. Your experimental procedure
leaves much to be desired, because of the subtlety of the whole area.
That said, what you've raised might indeed be correct, but there is
hardly anyone who posts here regularly with the expertise to comment.
If your comments are really about sinc-resampling, why on earth would
you not take them to music-dsp or comp.dsp, which are true platform-
neutral forums for such things? And if they are about possible
implementation issues in SRC, why have you not discussed your tests with
erik first?
I am not trying to dismiss the point you are trying to make - I
certainly do not know enough to even begin to comment. But I do think
that the way you have made it is really, really poor.