I play bass, and for the studio recording, the bass was DI'd
straight in, so I wouldn't think there would be too many problems
reproducing that (aside from the fact I don't own a DI box yet!).
I can certainly work on getting a good guitar sound though -
although I'm not 100% sure how I would tell if I got one.
By the way, the mix I made of the low-budget recording (no
effects, no lead guitar yet) is here:
http://drop.io/pretty_monster
So you can maybe get an idea what the tracking was like? This was
really a quick take (30 mins max) to see if this method worked at
all, and I am pretty happy, although nobody liked their
performances, and the click from ardour was not loud enough
through the laptop soundcard to be used to play the drums to..
I can post one of the individual tracks from that if you want.
.. I just put the rhythm guitar track with no effects in the
above drop. This was recorded by miking the amp (an old Fender
combo of some description) - Mic was Shure sm58.
James