30 Jun
2005
30 Jun
'05
12:44 p.m.
Hi,
I used CubaseSX for a solid year for Midi and recording work, and
while everything tended to work ok, still it took me several months to
learn to use the often quirky and non-instinctive interface. At one
point I decided to input one of my favorite challenging Beethoven
Piano pieces into the notation editor in Cubase. I got about half way
through and saved. When I went to re-open the project the next day
Cubase decided to apply some crazy algorithm turning the triplets into
awfully grouped 64th notes. It was terrible. I quit using Cubase
that day forever.
not to mention that generally I didn't like the soft-synths and
working on it gave me a kind of "icky" feeling. I've always had a
superstition that the Windows kernel has bad vibes.
Now I use Rosegarden and Qsynth and I love them both. And Ardour &
Jamin are great too. The linux tools certainly have more bugs but
they often dont have the clunky & poor work-around code that is
probably necessary to get the proprietary software ready to ship
ontime. and the bugs are predictable. I just try to stay away from
the behavior that produces them (although this isn't always possible
;-D ).
my 2-cents,
Greg
On 6/30/05, Dave Phillips <dlphillips(a)woh.rr.com> wrote:
MarC wrote:
Today I wouldn't recommend hobbyists should
use Linux Audio because in
this way they will always be hobbyists...
Actually, hobbyists will always be hobbyists until they acquire
professional levels of skill *and* put themselves to the test of
performance and/or distribution of their material. The gear they use
will not elevate their skills one jot. Owning a guitar does not confer
ability upon the owner.
I will say this about modern music technology, regardless of platform:
It makes a lot of bad music sound much better at the surface level.
However, in my case, I've found Linux Audio
very interesting to learn
a lot about the audio software implementation (obviously because of
the open source mentality) and also for understanding what kind of
things can be done (for a user/developper point of view). But for
productive work I simply can't recommend it because Pro Tools,
Reason,..., and a huge availability of VST plugins are too far from us.
Strange, I use VST plugins with Linux quite a lot here at Studio Dave.
Ardour seems to work pretty well for me too, and its price point is more
attractive to me. ;)
Best is to use what works for you to make your own music.
You can also thank whatever gods you believe in that M$ didn't make the
WAV format as proprietary as the DOC format...
Best,
dp