All good valid points Mark.  More power to him if he can make money and
get these really good products noticed.
Jan
On Fri, 2003-12-05 at 11:53, Mark Knecht wrote:
   Audacity is a
trivial download. There's no benefit to having it on CD
 by itself. A value-added CD packed with royalty free samples might be
 a different story, and the possibility of producing that has been
 discussed on the Audacity lists.
 Cheers
 Daniel
 
 My last post on this subject and then I'm done.
 Quote "There's no benefit to having it on CD by itself."
 Please do not think that you know what is, or is not, of benefit to someone
 else. What about a person that doesn't have a CD burner? What about a person
 who wants a backup copy so when the next release comes out and doesn't work
 he can go back? What about Grandma putting it under the Christmas tree for
 her grand kid? There are lots of 'reasonable' reasons for others that might
 not be 'reasonable' to you.
 So often people on these lists, and I'm not speaking specifically of you
 here Daniel, are *so* technically adept that they just plain forget what the
 real world is like for non-technical people. You don't know what people are
 doing out there. You don't know what their reasons are for wanting this. To
 many people this sort of purchase will be exactly like buying a tabloid at
 the checkout counter. I don't do that, but I don't propose taking away
 anyone's right to do it, nor do I spend any time worrying about whether they
 got their moneys worth. That's their business, not mine.
 This guy obviously got the message from you and others here through Ebay and
 has changed the way he's making his offer. That's positive. If someone wants
 to but it, I think that's great. If you want to sell Audacity, I think
 that's great too. Anything that gets people using the software is probably
 better in the long run for Open Source. I've turned so many people on to the
 few Windows versions of Open Source stuff that exist, like Audacity and
 ZynAddSubFx. I prefer to use them under Linux, but most musicians don't have
 a Linux box. I see this as one good way to eventually bring people to the
 Linux world. They start with this stuff on Windows, but they know it runs on
 Linux, and then maybe, someday, when they have a choice to make about
 operating systems they won't say 'there is no software for Linux'.
 Bye,
 Mark