Simon Williams wrote:
Ketil Thorgersen wrote:
Do a search on this list and you'll see that
this has been discussed
frequently!
I've looked but can only find one other thread on the subject which
didn't help me.
For piano the best free one I've found is
http://www.pianosounds.com/
That's got the same problem. It just sounds too tinny.
I've got a Yamaha YPP-35 at home. I would have thought it's a pretty
cheap digital piano- only 5 octaves, 8 voices and partially weighted
keys (though my parents seem to think it cost over 500 pounds at the
time, which seems slightly mad, but I could be wrong- it was 10-12 years
ago). But it sounds really nice- even the strings work well. All the
sounds are clean and simple- they aren't too muddy in the bass, they
don't resonate, they don't twang if I hit the keys hard, they aren't too
tinny on the higher notes, and the volume is balanced across the
keyboard. Why can't I get this sort of sound out of my laptop?
I've been using and loving the Yamaha audio patches for years. Someone
else on the list mentioned that a lot of the Yamaha audio sound is due
to the licensing of some very sophisticated wave guide audio patents
from MIT or some college like that. I suppose you could read the patents
and figure it out, but ...
I guess maybe I'm not really looking for
soundfonts. I don't really want
samples of real acoustic instruments because recording them is
impossibly difficult and leads to too much background noise. What I need
is to know how to make these sounds up on a synth. I don't mind it
sounding a bit electronic- actually I think I'd prefer it to some
extent. Then all I need to do is find a synth which handles the response
curve sanely and allows me to actually balance the thing across the
keyboard, instead of being too quiet in the bass and getting louder as I
work up.
Hmm, that almost sounds like an artifact of listening to audio through
laptop speakers. They all make the bass sound too quiet, at least to me.
Maybe I'll end up writing my own. But at the
moment I haven't
got the slightest clue how to get the sound I want out of a synth.
Yamaha uses samples of real acoustic instruments, plus their wave guide
software. I think most synthesizers these days essentially do the same
thing. Didn't someone on the list mention an article about how it's
impossible to synthesize a true piano sound?
--
David
gnome(a)hawaii.rr.com
authenticity, honesty, community