Steve Harris schrieb: Yes, this works with the object fiddle~, which is quite a good pitch tracker. ciao -- Frank Barknecht

There's LOTS of this stuff around. I don't know how well these three work, but I have asked in some other forums for recommendations. I'll let you know if I hear anything particularly good... Google is your friend... (Search on "audio to MIDI conversion") http://www.akoff.com/ http://www.harmony-central.com/Newp/2001/IntelliScore-40.html http://www.digital-ear.com/info.htm Mark -----Original Message----- From: linux-audio-user-admin(a)music.columbia.edu [mailto:linux-audio-user-admin@music.columbia.edu]On Behalf Of Steve Harris Sent: Thursday, September 12, 2002 2:11 AM To: linux-audio-user(a)music.columbia.edu Subject: Re: [linux-audio-user] monophonic audio -> MIDI On Wed, Sep 11, 2002 at 11:26:01 -0500, Will Benton wrote: I don't know of one, but if you are adventurous it should be possible to build one using pd with a frequency tracker, freq->note converter and midi out. ;) - Steve _______________________________________________ linux-audio-user mailing list linux-audio-user(a)music.columbia.edu http://music.columbia.edu/mailman/listinfo/linux-audio-user

wb, wb wrote: "Does anyone know of a good program that converts monophonic audio to MIDI data?" You got an answer you didn't like. I understand that. Next time ask the question you intend. wb wrote: "What good could they possibly do me, or anyone else on this list?" I use both environments to ensure I can use the best tools available. I suspect others do also. I think you suggest that all Linux users are closed minded Linux-only people? I think we disagree about that. It's OK to disagree. Mark -----Original Message----- From: linux-audio-user-admin(a)music.columbia.edu [mailto:linux-audio-user-admin@music.columbia.edu]On Behalf Of Will Benton Sent: Thursday, September 12, 2002 7:48 AM To: linux-audio-user(a)music.columbia.edu Subject: Re: [linux-audio-user] monophonic audio -> MIDI Those programs are all for Windows. What good could they possibly do me, or anyone else on this list? The fact is, I did a google search, and was inundated with Windows-only and proprietary, closed-source programs. It is difficult to narrow such a search by adding "Linux" or "UNIX" because so many "shareware music apps" have all of this worthless navigation frill that includes "Linux apps" on the sidebar. Also, I was curious to see if anyone had any experience with any programs -- i.e. "this sucks, don't waste time compiling it" or "this is unmaintained and won't compile but it's worth the effort". A company called GVOX made a $100 hardware device that looks promising, but they're out of business now. wb On Thu, Sep 12, 2002 at 07:37:13AM -0700, Mark Knecht wrote: know -- Will Benton | "Die richtige Methode der Philosophie wäre eigentlich willb(a)acm.org | die: Nichts zu sagen, als was sich sagen läßt...." _______________________________________________ linux-audio-user mailing list linux-audio-user(a)music.columbia.edu http://music.columbia.edu/mailman/listinfo/linux-audio-user

Greetings: Just thought you all might like to know that the demo of AKoff (one of the Windows apps Mark found on Google) ran fine under my somewhat-dated CodeWeaver's WINE installation. Nice app. Emulation environments count as Linux software too, and they may be of interest to Linux audio users. Best regards, == Dave Phillips The Book Of Linux Music & Sound at http://www.nostarch.com/lms.htm The Linux Soundapps Site at http://linux-sound.org jordan muscott wrote: --

Jordan, Neither do I. I run Windows apps under Linux all the time. Some using Wine. Some using Win4Lin. Some work well. Some do not. I disagree that it is, to quote 'blatantly obvious' as you say. At a minimum I would think that forward thinking, interested individuals /might/ want to know what's out there in the world. Possibly some of this will work with Alsa. Probably most of it won't. So what? This sort of tribalism gets us nowhere. My view - we're here because we have an interest in audio under Linux and sometimes you have to look outside of what exists in this environment to figure out where you're going. Flames -> /dev/null. If you don't like the content of an email on a reflector, do what I do, delete it or start a flame war. My inputs were given in a positive manner. wb chose the second. With best regards, Mark -----Original Message----- From: linux-audio-user-admin(a)music.columbia.edu [mailto:linux-audio-user-admin@music.columbia.edu]On Behalf Of jordan muscott Sent: Thursday, September 12, 2002 9:43 AM To: linux-audio-user(a)music.columbia.edu Subject: Re: [linux-audio-user] monophonic audio -> MIDI I think the point is that this list is called 'linux-audio-user', so we talk about linux-audio software. So someone shouldn't have to ask 'Does anyone know of some [whatever] software for _linux_ ,because it should be blatantly obvious. best regards, Jordan. _______________________________________________ linux-audio-user mailing list linux-audio-user(a)music.columbia.edu http://music.columbia.edu/mailman/listinfo/linux-audio-user

Will, My feelings we're hurt a bit. Don't worry about that. I'm sure by now that you've seen Dave Phillips' response saying at Akoff worked under Wine? Does this vindicate my response even slightly? ;-) There's a lot of great Windows stuff out there that we /can/ use. I do it. Others do to. Let's stay focused on what's great about Linux. This is one of them. In the end, if I had a good solution for you as a native Linux app, I would have given it to you. I didn't. I really wish I did, but... With best regards, Mark -----Original Message----- From: linux-audio-user-admin(a)music.columbia.edu [mailto:linux-audio-user-admin@music.columbia.edu]On Behalf Of Will Benton Sent: Thursday, September 12, 2002 11:08 AM To: linux-audio-user(a)music.columbia.edu Subject: RE: [linux-audio-user] monophonic audio -> MIDI Mark-- On Thu, 2002-09-12 at 12:40, Mark Knecht wrote: outside I can appreciate where you're coming from here, and don't disagree that looking at applications on other environments is a good way to gauge what might be useful to develop on Linux. However, I don't think that relying on Windows applications improves the state of Linux audio for anyone. Please, call me Will. I'm sorry if I hurt your feelings, but I don't think it's productive to second-guess my motives. I've been on the internet for a long time, and I've seen a lot of flames. I don't know that most people would characterize my response to your message as a flame. (On the other hand, I guess a similar number of people would characterize "just use Google" replies to a query as "flaming", so perhaps we're even after all. :-) Now we're completely OT for this (or likely any) list. In any case, I will be more specific in the future when I am looking for Linux-native software. wb -- Will Benton | "Die richtige Methode der Philosophie wäre eigentlich willb(a)acm.org | die: Nichts zu sagen, als was sich sagen läßt...." _______________________________________________ linux-audio-user mailing list linux-audio-user(a)music.columbia.edu http://music.columbia.edu/mailman/listinfo/linux-audio-user

On Thu, Sep 12, 2002 at 10:18:57AM -0500, Will Benton wrote: Oh no, you've opened another fun can o' worms. Check out rain: http://www.sci.fi/~mjkoskin/ -- Paul Winkler "Welcome to Muppet Labs, where the future is made - today!"