On Thu, Sep 3, 2009 at 2:53 PM, cunnilinux himself<cunnilinux(a)gmail.com> wrote:
... No further
need for musicianship or even any real technical knowledge of studio arts and practices.
Just switch to Windows, buy mucho VSTs, press the big "Proceed" button, and
away we go.
No more need to concern ourselves with context or relevance, we can at last wallow in an
orgy
of self-congratulatory pop.
i'd rather say "mainstream" than "pop".
audio production is mainly about ready solutions nowadays.
well, i was ironic in my posts, but i still don't consider linux as a
valuable platform for that game.
it's much better suited for doing custom & unusual things.
imnsho.
if i need something special that no one else uses, i'd definitely do
it with linux.
Or buy dedicated hardware analog modulars like Future Retro XS and
Analogue Solutions Red Square. IMHO they sound a lot better anyways,
you have a wide open sound palate, and its arguably a lot quicker if
your time is more important than money. Linux can sound great - I have
an Oasys that to me sounds incredible, especially for 2005 hardware -
but I've yet to hear anything on Linux free or commercial that comes
close to my ears. I tried Spectronics RMS and Reaper on Linux and
hated their sound. ymmv.
Don't get me wrong - most of the world is going software and nothing
is going to stop it. I haven't used anything besides Linux
professionally or personally in over 10 years. I use Rosegarden and
seq24 for a sequencer often, and I like Sonic Visualiser a lot. While
never using it as I'm not a DJ, I see the value of something like AL
for Linux.
My point is that if your goal is doing "doing custom & unusual things"
with audio on Linux then we're already there, though imho its sound is
inferior to dedicated hardware and its a huge PITA. To be fair, from
what I've heard its a PITA on mac and windows too. I myself prefer to
buy dedicated hardware. Anyways, If your goal is world domination via
a killer app like AL - then start a bounty on its features to make it
happen because its one of those areas where linux is following rather
than leading. I think the popularity of Reaper on Linux is also
evidence of that.
Sorry for my rant, I'm sure I'm in the minority. Just my 2 cents.
- R