De: Justin Smith <noisesmith(a)gmail.com> Objet: Re: [LAU] small usb/midi controllers À: tfric(a)learnkanji.ca Cc: linux-audio-user(a)lists.linuxaudio.org Date: Lundi 15 Décembre 2008, 3h56 I recently got an m-audio oxygen8 and a behringer bcf2000. they both work with alsa midi via usb, as simple as plugging them in, no configuration needed on my machine or the remote machine. The oxygen8 is about $100us new and has a two octave keyboard with large keys that have a nice feel, eight knobs, a spring-return pitch-bend wheel, and a mod wheel, and 6 midi transport control buttons, plus a midi out jack and a plug for a sustain pedal. The bcf2000 (should be about $200us) has 8 motorized continuous controller sliders, which send a cc when moved, and move when you send a cc to it. it also has 32 virtual knobs, eight accessable at a time, also settable via cc, with an led ring indicator on each, and a continuous turn knob, with multiple programmable settings for the rings (one looks like a good panning control, another volume, another trim maybe?). there are actually four groups of eight knobs, switchable with four buittons, and one group of knobs actually visible. each knob also doubles as a button that sends a note on/off on press/release (I think?) and has a pair of lit on/off buttons below it. Also there are some transport controls, learn functionality, and a number of factory presets for working with various daws. it also has plugs in the back for a sustain pedal and an expression pedal, a midi in, and two midi outs. The bcf2000 can do SO MUCH, I have had it for a month and have barely started looking into what it can do. It also broke on the way home when I first got it (I shoved it kind of ogrishly into an overpacked bike bag so I could bike it home), one of the fader buttons did not work. Then I moved to a new place, again shoving it kind of crudely into a bag for the move, and UNBROKE the damned thing, so now it is good as new. But it is a behringer, so I am treating it with kid gloves from here on. Both do exactly what they are designed to do, with minimum fuss (I have been writing custom software to use the bcf200 using preset 2 "generic mixer" preset, and have not tried using it with ardour yet, though I did find instructions for doing so online - I would be tempted to just make a pd patch or midish script to convert the output of the bcf2000 to something existing software can use, rather than learn it's arcane preset loading and editing procedure). Some company also made some cheap very tiny controlers, a drum pad, a set of sliders, and a keyboard, each under $50 (though I don't know anything about durability or how well they work). On Sun, Dec 14, 2008 at 4:30 PM, <tfric(a)learnkanji.ca> wrote: of knobs and sliders Sonic Cell. The keys (not even novation, m-audio, korg nanoKontrol. Alsa? Does anyone know http://lists.linuxaudio.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-audio-user _______________________________________________ Linux-audio-user mailing list Linux-audio-user(a)lists.linuxaudio.org http://lists.linuxaudio.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-audio-user

Subject: Re: [LAU] small usb/midi controllers Thanks for all the advice, I think I'll go with the Korg NanoKontrol for now unless I can find a cheap Oxygen 8. The Behringer bcf2000's overkill for me - I just need a few knobs for effects and synth parameters. If I'm going to spend that much I'd rather have a second keyboard than extra CC's. I found a good french site with a list of midi controls that work in linux: http://www.linuxmao.org/tikiwiki/tiki- index.php?page=Les+surfaces+de+contr%C3%B4le Les surface de controle fonctionnant sous Linux (liste non-exhaustive à compléter par vos expériences) * Berhinger BFC et BRC 2000 * Evolution UC16 * Evolution UC33 * M-audio Oxygen 8 * M-audio Oxygen49 fonctionne sans probleme * Novation Remote25 * Vestax VCI-100 * Korg NanoKontrol (éditeur testé sous wine et ubuntu, aucun problème) * Akai MPD24 * KORG M3 reconnu en USB _______________________________________________ Linux-audio-user mailing list Linux-audio-user(a)lists.linuxaudio.org http://lists.linuxaudio.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-audio-user

> I am interested in getting a midi controller with lots of knobs and > sliders for controlling soft synths, effects and my Roland Sonic > Cell. The keyboard I use doesn't have any controls but the keys (not > even pitch/modultation). > > I've been looking at the 2 octave keyboards from novation, m-audio, > behringer and roland specifically. I also like the korg nanoKontrol. > > Can anyone recomend something that works well with Alsa? Does anyone > know of any problems with using these through usb? >